Opinions needed

[dixie]

are these two pics of the same deer? ::huh:

[Dog Hunter]

Don't see but one picture

[dixie]

pic

[GeauxLSU]

I'm going with "no".
Hunt/fish safely,
Phil

[rip18]

The general conformation & color look the same. Looking at the deer cam pic, I count 5 points on the right main beam, while on the mount, I count 4 points.

I am assuming that there is a G1 on the deer cam pic & that the G4 really is attached behind the ear. I don't see the G4 on the mount, but it could be the angle & lack of clarity on my monitor.

Based on what appears to be a major discrepancy, I have to say, "I don't believe they are pictures of the same deer."

[Cranium]

Nope

[huntnnut]

I'd say they are two separate deer also.

[Phillip Thurmond]

I would say no based on the G2's I feel two different deer

[Hunk]

after counting the points they look like 2 different bucks.

[Handgunner]

I'll echo the "no" also.

Dixie, did somebody steal your mount? :p ;)

[Ga-Spur]

I don't think so.

[Dustin Pate]

Another negative here.

[HT2]

I don't think so......

They don't look the same to me..... ::huh:

[dbodkin]

I say no

[nevamiss270]

i'll have to go with the no

[highcountry]

Steve, ask RIchard and Steve. They can tell you for sure as they personally know every deer out thtere by name.......HaHa. No it is not the same. Are the clubs still there or did they wash away into the lake?????? I am goona be out there Sunday I think.

[horsecreek]

2 separate. the 1st pic he has an extra small point on his right side. the 2nd pic does not.

[WildBuck]

I will have to stick with the majority and also say no.

[dixie]

Looks like we all agree. the member in the pic with the mount sent me that pic, and wanted to know if I thought it was the same deer, I didn't think it was either, but wanted some others opinions about it. P.S. High C. your tarp is torn all to pieces, the storm got it.

[SouthPaw Draw]

I would say they are 2 different deer - because of different looking G2's

[Jim Thompson]

Looks like we all agree. the member in the pic with the mount sent me that pic, and wanted to know if I thought it was the same deer, I didn't think it was either, but wanted some others opinions about it. P.S. High C. your tarp is torn all to pieces, the storm got it.
Dang Steve, what a way to let a man know his tarp is all messed up....mixed in the middle of a post:D

Dont look like the same deer to me either.

Jim

[Meriwether Mike]

Does not look the like the same deer to me as well.

[gacowboy]

Looks like 2 different deer. :flag: :flag: :flag:

[sr.corndog]

SORRY TRY AGAIN! :flag:

[BassWorm]

Looks like two different deer to me also.

[gabowman]

Nope, two different deer.

GB