I tried that one in the marsh in Apalachicola this spring. Was successful, but didn't like the fact that a couple of reds hammered it so hard it went deep into their throat and was hard to retrieve with the weedless apparatus. Luckily they were slot fish that went into the cooler. I was worried about killing a small or large fish with this method. Was thinking about taking the hook off at the split ring and using a jig head instead without the weedless guards. I never got around to trying that but switched to a Redfish Magic and was tearing up the trout and the red fish. They still hit it hard and sometimes hook themselves behind my eyeball but was much easier to retrieve from the fish's mouth and is still very weedless. Doesn't even pick up the floating grass.