My 10mm and .357 doesn't get pass thru's on the majority of the hogs I've shot with it. That's using Hornady XTP (both guns), Speer gold dots and ball ammo(10mm). I have had better penetration with 230 gr hard cast lead out of a 45 acp but the recovered hard cast bullets are not expanding.
I would recommend that you took the pistol your most familiar with and most accurate with, hopefully there the same.
16,17A,17B RFA & clubs opposed; Pew, EDF, CCA supported