jbird1
Senior Member
Great discussion jbird. Since buying a piece of OC ground in 2011 and spending a crazy amount of time improving habitat to hold deer, here's what I know for certain - Any attempt to manage for mature deer (3.5 and older), is an exercise in frustration and futility. But...I continue to try. Just too much hunting pressure with so many clubs in the county. Add a nearly 3 month long firearms season to the mix and and good looking 2.5 yr old bucks sprouting 90 to 110 inches of bone, most hunters gonna have a hard time passing on those. And here's the reality of it - If it's legal, who am I to even suggest someone else hunt by my standards. I wish folks would pass on younger bucks but I respect their choice to harvest whatever makes them happy. And I don't give it a second thought any more. Like a lot of you guys, I love seeing deer from the stand and particularly bucks.
To your point, I think you are spot on as far as improving deer numbers - better to shoot a yearling buck than a doe. If we didn't have the deer numbers we do I'd be all for shooting young bucks and letting the does walk.
That's what I like about your place TC...it's a Dictatorship!
As you undoubtedly know, moving the needle philosophically amongst a group of hunters with varying ideas about what hunting means to them can be a task that can prove difficult and takes some time. I truly believe that's why we have settled where we are on our club. From one end of the spectrum to the other, we settled somewhere in the middle after 40 years. I'm hoping we can avoid the yo-yo effect with the herd and just hunt.
Good talk, Guys!