Ok so usually at 4.5 they get mass but at their base they seem rather narrow like a 3.5 plus they are in velvet which adds thickness for this time of year pics.. No belly sag no loose neck and that starts around 4.5. Plus the darker one has a younger face . I’m just trying to relearn my habits so I can age on the hood. Because 5 years ago I would be harvesting one of them this year. Looking for a Booner btw these deer are located in Kentucky when I hunted in south GA never seen these beauties there.I think you may be a year light. 4.5 this season is my guess.
3.5 is a good guess. Brisket isn't pronounced, no belly sag, etc. This deer is in his prime.