Those gummies will catch anything that swims....Blane is a freaking genius when it comes to thinking up patterns....I was fortunate enough to learn from him when I lived in VA. Awesome guy.
Red
I've fished a gummy minnow on several outings and didn't catch a thing. They have a good texture but absolutely no movement.
I'm a steamer fool, Red. I have many friends that chase all kinds of different fish and they've had the same result. I have found that other flies vastly outperform it. I may give it another try because I do like the feel of the stuff.
I don't scold the person that fishes Y2Ks and San Juan Worms.
And don't want someone scolding me about fish'n with Beadhead Wooly Buggers with spinners on them.
At the end of the day its just ty'n and fish'n.
Is the fact ,that it is your livelihood ,that is clouding your view.