^^^ ThisI really can't answer if it's the same scope or not. If it were me, I'd do what I always do when I'm not sure which scope to buy. I'd go somewhere who sells both and do a side by side comparison, and let my eyes decide.
I will add this though... Redfield is an old company who was basically phased out, and bought out by Leupold. That being said, the old original Redfield Widefield, Illuminators, etc, are old Redfield models, that were outstanding scopes, in their time, but are no longer covered by any warranties, since the take over of Leupold. So, if Leupold decides to drop the Redfiled line of scopes, at some point, once again, those new Redfield scopes will not be covered.
All of that being said, if the scopes are similar, I'd go with the Leupold brand.
When you say the redfield moved on, do mean it went ahead of your vx1 or you got rid of it?With scopes at a similar price break, I've used SXS low light comparisons to make most of my decisions. The biggest differences in such scopes is normally in the lens coatings a particular scope has.
I've had the new Redfield and VX1 in such a comparison and the Redfield moved on. I have had several Nikon Prostaffs as well, but now prefer Leupold when I purchase.
FWIW, I now own scopes from Bushnell, Burris, Hawke, Leopld, Minox, Nikon, Redfield, Sig Sauer, Vortex, Weaver and Zeiss.
When you say the redfield moved on, do mean it went ahead of your vx1 or you got rid of it?