Which one are you?

Thread starter #1

Throwback

Senior Member
Here's a hotlink:http://www.lewrockwell.com/dmccarthy/dmccarthy14.html

Are You a Neocon?
by Daniel McCarthy

Regular readers of LRC or other right-of-center sites are sure to have seen terms like "neoconservative" and "paleo-libertarian" from time to time. A quick Google search can explain what the words mean, but definitions don’t really answer the more interesting and important question – which one are you?

Naturally you might be neither "paleo" nor "neo." But for those who’d like to find out I devised a quick quiz during a spell of procrastination a few months back. Here it is. After answering twenty questions it’ll give you my impression of which of ten modern American ideologies is the best fit for you, along with links to sites representing the philosophy of each.

There’s no shortage of political quizzes on the ‘net, but how many others includes "paleoconservative" and "third way" as categories? Not many (or any) that I’ve seen. And to be thoroughly immodest, this quiz is less slanted than most too. I’m a pale-something myself though, so if you find bias that’s where I’m coming from. Other than that the major flaw is that I don’t know modern left-wing ideologies at all well, so the categories of "radical," "liberal" and "third-way" probably are not how leftists would classify themselves.

The quiz questions are mostly about public policy. An alternative method would have been to ask general philosophical questions, or even to ask for interpretations of historical events. I chose the policy-oriented approach because it seemed most straightforward and clear.

Here, in brief, are the ideologies that the quiz examines. You’ll probalby want to take the quiz first though. The sketches below aren’t an answer key, but you can probably deduce from the definitions how someone of a given ideology would answer a particular question. That’s the entire principle of the quiz, after all.

Centrist – Just what it sounds like. Someone who doesn’t have any particularly strong ideological leanings in any direction.

Conservative – Specifically a "fusionist" conservative of the National Review - Heritage Foundation mold. Someone who believes in traditional morality and capitalism, and the need for a limited government to allow both to flourish.

Left-libertarian – The quiz uses a mild definition of a left-libertarian, an anti-statist who is somewhat fearful of corporate and religious influence on public life.

Liberal – Supports economic regulation to promote social justice and takes a progressive stance toward moral or cultural issues.

Libertarian – A libertarian opposes most or all government activites. Does not favor much or any government support for either moral or economic systems.

Neoconservative – A "neocon" is more inclined than other conservatives toward vigorous government in the service of the goals of traditional morality and pro-business policies. Tends to favor a very strong foreign policy of America as well.

Paleoconservative – "Paleocons" want less US involvement in foeign affairs than other conservatives and oppose mass immigration. They are also more favorably disposed toward the South and the idea of secession, or at least decentralization, than neoconservatives.

Paleo-libertarian – Similar to other libertarians except for oppostion to mass immigration, and shares the paleocon appreciation of the South.

Radical – Critical of bouregois morality and strongly opposed to capitalism and willing to use state power to achieve desired ends.

Third-way – More supportive of foreign intervention than liberals and less supportive of economic regulation, coupled with more-or-less progressive social views. "Third-way" is to liberal what neoconservative is to conservative.


June 26, 2001

Daniel McCarthy [send him mail] is a graduate student in classics at Washington University in St. Louis.
 
Thread starter #2

Throwback

Senior Member
I'm a paleo-con,paleo-libertarian, and a conservative, top 3.

T
 
I ended up a Conservative, im shocked.
 

Ta-ton-ka chips

GONetwork Member
I am the opposite of 1fishinfool, ::ke:, I think for myself, don't have to "cut and paste" my arguements, and don't have to resort to labels or name calling to get across my opinions.
According to the test I am a Libertarian, which in my case means the test was accurate :cool:
 
1. Conservative
2. Paleoconservative
 

1fishinfool

Senior Member
Ta-ton-ka chips said:
I am the opposite of 1fishinfool
Thank's, I am in actuality 100% Paleoconservative, don’t want to align myself with you dope smokin’ baby killin’ illegal immigrant lovin’ liberal bunch losers anyway.

:smash:
 

Ta-ton-ka chips

GONetwork Member
1fishinfool said:
Thank's, I am in actuality 100% Paleoconservative, don’t want to align myself with you dope smokin’ baby killin’ illegal immigrant lovin’ liberal bunch losers anyway.

:smash:
Congratulations, you wrote that (I assume) all by yourself!
HOWEVER, I don't smoke dope, but should have the right to do so especially if I was going through chemotherapy!
I've never killed a human baby, and its a tragedy if that's what a mother chooses to do with her body - but its her choice and thankfully I'll never have to make that choice.
And let's not forget this country was founded by immigrants and you need to come to grips with that! I believe our borders should be open to LEGAL immigration so others may become productive and make this country even greater!
I voted for Bush and support him on the war on terror (which goes against the Libertarian Party line) but I'm disappointed with him for lack of action against illegal aliens and he's doubled the size of the Federal Government.
Republicans (conservatives) cave to Liberals on every issue and meet them halfway. How can they walk without a backbone? If you believe in something then stand up for it!
Everytime you compromise you lose.
And by the way - I'm not a loser - I run a fairly successful businesss and now I'm going home to bed. :clap:
 

Branchminnow

GONetwork Senator Area 51
Just a plain old bible thumpin' conservative.
 

Branchminnow

GONetwork Senator Area 51
biggame11 said:
Minnow you know you are just run of the mill crazy nothing else ::ke:


O yeah Have a great day!

I just had to get the first one in today. :p
A thick skin I do have my freind.
 

dbone

Outdoor Cafe Moderator
Interesting !! No one questioned the equality or the slant of the test , Its no wonder so many of you stated you were confused , you saw , you complyed and you labeled yourselves , good sheep just watch out for the cliff ahead :rofl:
 

Branchminnow

GONetwork Senator Area 51
biggame11 said:
It took you long enough to see it.
:offtopic:

Hope to see you at the Perry Buckarama, come see me win my truck on Sunday :fine:
Been putting out fires all morning and all day.
 
Top