Tough decision cause the last two pics have the horns closer to the camera and at that angle the deer looks smaller and horns bigger. For me, they'd all be bow kills but maybe not gun shooters.
No. 3 would be a shooter no matter what I had in my hand ! Bow, rifle, rock, etc.
Of course it all depends on the situation. If I had a piece of property that had bucks of that caliber walking all over it, I may pass on any and all of them. BUT, since I have never sat foot on a piece of property like that, all of them would be in trouble at some time or another.
I don't trust deer in velvet. The always look bigger than they are. The first one needs another year for me. But I have to say that looking at the bodies, they all appear to be mature deer.