He is old enough that he has bred some does, so "culling" him is a fruitless endeavor. If you want to shoot him, by all means, shoot him. But don't think you'll be doing the herd any favors by pulling the trigger.
Definitely not trying to just put him down. That is whole reason behind me asking for advice. I have really good genetics on this property. He is just the odd ball. Here is one of my rising stars. Too me he is way too young to be carrying this kind of head gear. Can’t wait to see what he will be in 4 years.