Good advice. I had rather her retrieve 1 than me shoot 100.I've only ever seen people with dogs specifically there to make retrieves they weren't shooting. If you're at the position that the birds are flying too mostly you'll probably be missing shots while your dog is making retrieves. Personally I'd rather see my dog make a retrieve than shoot a bird thrown out of a tower. With that being said I've shot a lot of pheasants that were thrown out of a tower that my dog wasn't there to retrieve. If they'll allow it I'd take your pup.