Lthomas, you are right about that. That's why I chose a poplar. I can't believe that pine is the most prefered. I hate climbing pines because of the noisy bark and sap.
Speaking of coming down fast, I don't know what kind it was, but I came down a wet one a few years ago like it was an iced covered flag pole. I was at my hunting height and was shifting the stand around the tree so I would not have to lean against a broken off dead branch when she let loose. Caught my armpit on that broken limb but kept on going down.
I like sweet gum and poplar trees, nice straight ones with not many low limbs to trim or get in the way. I really like ones that are "popular" with the deer movement!
I have basically no preference, opting for the LIVE tree offering the best set up. It tends to end up being poplar, pine or gum once I make the setup. I avoid hickory too, and don't particularly like climbing oaks.
IMO what little noise a climber makes most times is thought a natural sound by wildlife. A friend of mine shot a stud a few years back that charged in to the sound of his climber interacting with the tree as he climbed at daybreak. The buck ended up straight under him and he administered coupe de grace with his tree still swaying too and fro...that said I do attempt to be quiet as possible.
Poplar if at all possible but I'll climb whichever I feel is best suited for placement. Climbed some palm trees on Wassaw but you have to be prepared to share your stand with the scorps.
Power pole tree. no need to adjust your stand on the way up, usually on a prepared shooting lane and you can carry a flourescent light bulb and not need batteries.
Pine is the favorite mainly because i hunt mainly in planted pines. The few odd hardwoods that have grown up are not where i need them. My main problem is finding a pine big enough to climb.