PB&J Debate

[menhadenman]

Crunchy, toasted wheat, and HONEY

 

[TJay]

Here lately I've been enjoying my PB&J on Dave's Good Seed bread. One of my favorites was a PB&J with blueberry jalapeno jelly, can't find the jelly anymore.

 

[Ruger#3]

First world problems?

Those drizzling S. American chocolate over Latin American bananas would know.

 

[Geffellz18]

I like Peter Pan honey roast, jelly don't matter

That is some good stuff there now!

Don’t eat them often, but may have to tomorrow based on this thread.

Not too picky about mine, but my current preferred method is always peanut butter on one side, jelly on the other in similar quantities then married together.
My favorite bread now for them is the natures own perfectly crafted multigrain bread. The same brand in brioche or white is on point too though.
When I was younger, I used to put SC&O chips on half. Was good stuff!

 

[WaltL1]

Far be it from me to tell a man how to eat a PBJ, but here's how I do it.

White bread, preferably the kind for Texas Toast.

A big, overdone glop of smooth peanut butter on one side, and a big overdone glop of jelly on the other.

Once put together, the thing should weigh at least half a pound.

Pile of plain Lays Tater Chips and a dill spear on the side.

*Pre mixed PB&J ruins the whole dang thing. That's what they did at the elementary lunchroom...

Pile of plain Lays Tater Chips and a dill spear on the side.

Ever put the tater chips in the PB&J sandwich?
Its awesome.

 

[Railroader]

Ever put the tater chips in the PB&J sandwich?
Its awesome.

Yes.

 

[35 Whelen]

Smooth peanut butter on both slices of bread, preserves everywhere except the edges, the peanut butter seals the edges together so the preserves don't leak out when you take a bite.

 

[K80Shooter]

blueberry jalapeno jelly

Make your own,

Blueberry Pepper Jelly Recipe - Food.com

Supposedly this is the recipe for Lauri Jo Bennett's blueberry pepper jelly that's sold nationwide. Other flavors may be made, such as strawberry, pe

www.food.com

 

[TJay]

Make your own,

Blueberry Pepper Jelly Recipe - Food.com

Supposedly this is the recipe for Lauri Jo Bennett's blueberry pepper jelly that's sold nationwide. Other flavors may be made, such as strawberry, pe

www.food.com

I may have to give that a whirl when my blueberries come in.

 

[mrs. hornet22]

Peanut butter, jelly, mayo mixed in a bowl. Spread on soft white bread.

 

[redeli]

Peanut butter on one slice,,jelly(either grape or apple) on the other slice of bread. Plain and simple.

 

[Dustin Pate]

I'll eat them most any way. But, my personal preference is white bread (non-toasted), crunchy PB, grape jelly, and most important...it has to have mayo.

 

[WOODIE13]

Smooth peanut butter, strawberry or strawberry/rhubarb jam on potato or wheat bread, big cold glass of milk

 

[Raylander]

Gotta have enough PB to bondo a car. Just a little bit of jelly

First I ever heard of Mayo?
Some of y’all are wild!

 

[Stob]

Mmm...good!

 

[WOODIE13]

Mmm...good!

View attachment 1304040

Grill cheese definitely

 

[gb1194]

Not toasted, creamy, mixed. Prefer a thicker preserve over store bought jelly but I’ll take either. Tall glass of milk.

 

[NCHillbilly]

Peanut butter, jelly, mayo mixed in a bowl. Spread on soft white bread.

You definitely lost me with the mayonnaise.

 

[Dustin Pate]

You definitely lost me with the mayonnaise.

If there is bread involved, it needs mayo!

 

[NCHillbilly]

If there is bread involved, it needs mayo!