PB&J Debate

[NCHillbilly]

One of my sisters used to eat nanner and mayonnaise sammiches. Yuck.

 

[ambush80]

Two slices brioche, on one slice extra crunchy peanut butter (Jiff or Peter Pan, not 'organic'/farmer's market), chopped toasted macadamias sprinkled on the peanut butter. On the other slice: strawberry or quince jam and fresh jalapeno chips. Assemble sandwich and dredge through either french toast batter or light tempura batter. Deep fry until golden brown, slice in half and serve with powdered sugar and caramel drizzle.

I just made that up, but I'm sure it's a thing somewhere.

Maybe a PBJ Unchained contest?

 

[Geffellz18]

One of my sisters used to eat nanner and mayonnaise sammiches. Yuck.

I got a say-Ate those as a kid and actually enjoyed them. Haven’t had one in probably 25+ years though.
It’s sort of like spam, beanie wienes, potted meat, veener sausages & the like-I ain’t against them, but if there are better options, I’m opting for them!

 

[antharper]

One of my sisters used to eat nanner and mayonnaise sammiches. Yuck.

I can eat that but never even considered putting mayo on my pb&j .

 

[fishfryer]

One of my sisters used to eat nanner and mayonnaise sammiches. Yuck.

It ain’t just a mountain thang, my wife and her family eats them too.

 

[redeli]

nanner sandwich with peanut butter and mayo is most excellent

 

[35 Whelen]

Peanut butter, jelly, and banana sandwich is good, however, no to mayonnaise.

 

[elfiii]

Man, y'all are out there somewhere in another dimension. I love PBJs. But, not them PBJs.
100% non-toasted or hot (toasted PBJ: )
Not mixed. Peanut butter on one piece of bread, jelly on the other. Grape or muscadine jelly only for a PBJ. And crunchy peanut better is unclean, and an instrument of Satan. Creamy only.

So you're a traditionalist.

 

[NCHillbilly]

After all this discussion, I made me one for lunch today. It's sitting on my desk in my dinner bucket, with some plain Lay's chips.

 

[ambush80]

I'm still a bit emotionally destabilized by the actions of you Pre-mixers......

 

[JonathanG2013]

I prefer spreading crunch peanut butter then grape or scupadine jelly. Not into the mixing stuff. It is to messy.

Do you anyone of your prefer a certain brand of peanut butter? I like Jiff.

 

[Raylander]

So, how are y’all cutting them in half?

Diagonal? Or crossways?

 

[WOODIE13]

Wife is making one now on her homemade bread, strawberry jam, smooth peanut butter and a cold glass of milk, hold the mayo

 

[WOODIE13]

So, how are y’all cutting them in half?

Diagonal? Or crossways?

Quartered

 

[Raylander]

Quartered

Don’t your PB get away?

 

[WOODIE13]

Don’t your PB get away?

Right in the mouth

 

[NCHillbilly]

So, how are y’all cutting them in half?

Diagonal? Or crossways?

Not. I'm eating mine right now. Whole.

 

[NCHillbilly]

It's good.

 

[WOODIE13]

Better when someone else makes the for you

 

[Raylander]

Whole

You sir, are a savage