atlashunter
Senior Member
Come on, it wont hurt (much), you can admit they tell the same story
And by the same story, I mean the "big picture".
I already acknowledged that a long time ago. “He said something and then died.” Ok... If that’s as deep as we want to go in looking at the accounts in evaluating their reliability then yes at that high level they are in agreement. That’s not the question we are discussing. The question I have repeated many times now is what were his last words? And the answer to that question depends on which gospel you read. They are not the same in their answer to that question and I already explained how that difference could be demonstrated. Police don’t put every witness together in a room so they can get their story straight if they want to know the veracity of a witness. They take their accounts separately and then compare the accounts in detail.